Emotionally Based School Absence (EBSA)

Children experiencing anxiety, distress or challenges at home can become persistently absent from school. Too often, the system’s response focuses on attendance and sanctions rather than the underlying wellbeing needs driving that absence, with limited early identification of at-risk children and insufficient whole-family support to prevent things escalating. As a result, absence becomes entrenched, educational engagement declines, and young people’s mental health worsens.

We want to see schools move from punitive attendance enforcement to early intervention that supports the mental health and wellbeing of children who are frequently absent — helping them re-engage with education consistently and positively.

The problem

Although emotionally based school avoidance (EBSA) is not separately recorded in national attendance statistics, research suggests it affects between 1% and 5% of pupils, equivalent to approximately 90,000–450,000 children and young people across England.

Source: BMJ Mental Health (2024), Perfect storm: emotionally based school avoidance in the post-COVID-19 pandemic context

The experience today

The case study below illustrates how emotionally based school avoidance (EBSA) can play out in practice. While fictional, the journey was co-designed with the Fixing Futures Young People’s Panel and draws on themes from our wider engagement with young people, families and practitioners, alongside the evidence.

Meet Leah

Leah is 13 and lives in Ipswich with her parents and older brother. Her parents moved to the UK before she was born and have always placed a lot of importance on her education.

Leah is academic, motivated and wants to do well. Teachers know her as creative, thoughtful and capable.

School feels overwhelming

After difficulties with a group of friends, Leah becomes increasingly nervous around other pupils. Break and lunch are particularly difficult, and she starts worrying about school the night before.

One morning, Leah becomes overwhelmed and cannot return to class. Other pupils see what happens, leaving her embarrassed and frightened about going back. She takes a few days off, intending to return once things feel calmer.

But when Monday comes around, Leah feels physically sick at the thought of walking through the gates. She cannot properly explain why. She knows she is supposed to be at school and feels guilty watching her parents worry, but the fear feels stronger than anything else.

Her distress is treated as an attendance problem

Leah’s mum contacts the school first. She knows Leah is distressed but isn’t familiar with where families are supposed to go for mental health support and assumes school will know what to do.

At first, the focus is on getting Leah back into lessons. The family receives attendance calls and warning letters, and when Leah manages to attend for short periods, she is faced with missed work and consequences for things she has not completed.

Her mum returns to school and tries to explain that Leah is not simply choosing to stay home. Eventually, school suggests speaking to the GP about her anxiety.

By then, Leah has started to feel that adults see her as someone who is refusing school. Her mum worries that the school thinks she is not doing enough to make her attend.

Her mum keeps looking for help

Leah’s mum makes a GP appointment and explains what has been happening. She is given advice and possible routes for further support, but nothing changes quickly enough to make getting through the school gates feel possible.

Meanwhile, the attendance process continues. The family attends meetings, receives further warnings and eventually faces a fine. On one occasion, a member of school staff visits the house to encourage Leah to come in. Leah stays upstairs, terrified and ashamed that things have reached this point.

Her mum goes back to school again. She asks whether Leah could use a quieter entrance, start later, have some learning at home or meet the same trusted adult each morning.

Some things are tried briefly, others are difficult to arrange, and there is no clear plan that Leah feels able to manage.

Eventually, school starts to fall away

Weeks become months. Work is sometimes sent home, but it does not always match what Leah’s class is doing. She starts falling behind and becomes anxious about how much she has missed.

Messages from friends become harder to answer. Leah worries about people asking where she has been or staring when she comes back. Even on days when she feels slightly better, the thought of returning after such a long absence feels overwhelming.

She still wants to learn. She talks about her GCSEs and worries about what will happen in the future. But the longer she is away, the less she can imagine herself going back.

Every day away makes returning harder

Attempts to return become shorter and less frequent. Meetings increasingly focus on whether Leah can realistically remain at the school and what other options might be available.

Alternative provision and home education are discussed. Her parents had never planned to educate Leah at home, but after months of trying to get her back into school without a plan that feels manageable, they begin to feel there is little other choice.

Eventually, Leah stops attending altogether.

What began as fear about going back after a difficult experience has become a much bigger break from education. Leah has lost contact with friends, fallen behind academically and become more anxious and isolated along the way

Leah’s absence does not begin because she no longer cares about school. She is frightened and overwhelmed, but still wants to learn. However, the response she and her family receive focuses largely on getting her back into the classroom, rather than understanding why she is struggling to attend. Without early support to help her return gradually and safely, each day away makes going back harder, increasing the risk of long-term disengagement from education.

What We Found

We brought together evidence from a literature review, practitioner interviews and lived-experience engagement to understand why school avoidance happens — and who is most affected.

Literature review

  • School Avoidance is linked to anxiety, emotional distress, bullying, transitions, academic pressure, sensory overload and unmet needs in school.
  • Punitive attendance responses, including fines or pressure-based approaches, are repeatedly identified as ineffective or harmful.
  • Effective responses are more likely to involve trusted adults, safe spaces, parent engagement, flexible adjustments, phased returns and whole-school approaches.

Practitioner interviews

  • Attendance difficulties are often linked to anxiety, neurodiversity, bullying, family stress or unmet need (broadly grouped as mental health needs).
  • Schools may use attendance or behaviour systems when the underlying issue was emotional distress.
  • Neurodivergent children were repeatedly identified as particularly vulnerable where school environments were overwhelming or inflexible.
  • Trusted adults, stable or nurturing environments, flexible adjustments and family engagement were more effective than enforcement-led approaches.

Lived experience interviews

  • School avoidance was linked to feeling unsafe, overwhelmed, anxious, bullied or misunderstood.
  • Frustration when schools focused on attendance rather than whether the child felt safe or able to learn.
  • Positive experiences reported commonly involved trusted adults, flexible support, calm environments, clear communication and support that addressed root causes. 
  • Young people could spend long periods out of education when school, CAMHS or other services did not respond early enough.

“When I stopped going to school,I became very, very isolated… and the more isolated I became, the more lonely I became, the more depressed I became.” 

Groups most likely to be affected

School avoidance doesn’t affect every pupil equally — some groups face a much higher risk of becoming persistently absent.

Where is the need greatest?

Why it matters

When systems are unable to respond effectively to emotionally based school avoidance, children & young people can become progressively disconnected from mainstream education. Over time, this increases reliance on more intensive and costly forms of support, and contributes to poorer long-term outcomes.

Reintegration becomes increasingly complex and costly

Prolonged absence makes reintegration increasingly difficult, and increases the likelihood of needing Alternative Provision, tutoring or other education outside the mainstream — routes not all families can navigate equally. Restoring participation requires more intensive and coordinated support the longer a child has been away from school.

Annual Alternative Provision (AP) placements for a young person cost around £18,000 a year on average, compared with roughly £6,771 on average per pupil for mainstream school spending.

Poor long-term life outcomes and higher public cost

Absence disrupts education and the transition into adulthood, with effects that carry well beyond school.

Persistent absence is associated with a 3.9x higher risk of becoming NEET (31% vs 8%) and a 6.3x higher risk of persistent NEET (19% vs 3%).

Mainstream education loses its ability to act as the primary protective environment

The longer absence continues, the harder participation becomes to restore, and the more a child’s support ends up sitting outside mainstream school.

A CAMHS inpatient admission costs between £77,000- £100,000, compared with roughly £350 for six school-based counselling or CBT sessions.

Why is the system failing?

Building a better system

We want to see schools shift from attendance enforcement to attendance restoration — building pathways around each child’s needs, not statutory requirements.

To support this shift, we have identified the following performance drivers that should guide how services operate:

What a better journey could look like

Earlier identification of emotional distress and unmet needs, combined with timely, personalised and coordinated support across education, health and SEND services, will improve outcomes around children & young people’s wellbeing, engagement with learning and sustained school attendance.