Effectiveness of In-School Mental Health Support

School communities play a central role in supporting children and young people’s mental health, and the Government has committed to deploying Mental Health Support Teams (MHSTs) in every school in England. However, significant variation remains in the availability, accessibility, quality and delivery of mental health support across schools, including which pupils are able to access MHST provision. There is also limited clarity on whether these interventions improve wellbeing, prevent escalation or lead to better long-term outcomes. This makes it difficult to identify gaps in support, assess impact, target resources effectively or scale what works.

Our aim is to strengthen outcomes-focused performance management and system learning for mental health support in schools, improving access, quality and effectiveness so that what works becomes best practice across the system.

The problem

“Almost half (46.9%) of 11-16 year olds with a probable mental disorder did not report accessing mental health and wellbeing support at school”

Source: NHS England (2023), Mental Health of Children and Young People in England, 2023

The experience today

The case study below illustrates how ineffective mental health support in schools may play out in practice. While fictional, the journey was co-designed with the Fixing Futures Young People’s Panel and draws on themes from our wider engagement with young people, families and practitioners, alongside the evidence.

Meet Jade

Jade is 15 and lives with her parents and younger sister. She is preparing for her GCSEs and has always done well at school.

She likes quiet, structured lessons and goes to chess club with two close friends. She rarely gets into trouble and usually hands her work in on time, so teachers tend to think of her as someone who is doing fine.

Small changes begin to appear

At home, Jade’s parents are going through a difficult period in their relationship. Arguments become more frequent, and Jade often finds herself listening from her bedroom or trying to keep things calm for her younger sister. She doesn’t want to make things harder for either parent, so she keeps growing anxiety to herself.

At school, the changes are easy to miss. Jade stops putting her hand up in lessons. She struggles to concentrate and starts taking much longer over work that used to come easily. Some days she sits in the toilets at lunchtime rather than meeting her friends. Eventually, she stops going to chess club.

Her grades are still relatively good, so nobody asks much about what has changed.

Jade tries to ask for help

Jade doesn’t know what mental health support her school offers. She only finds out there is someone she can speak to when a friend mentions it.

After a particularly difficult week at home, she works up the courage to speak to her year lead with her friend’s support. She doesn’t tell them everything but says she is finding things hard and struggling to concentrate.

The year lead is kind and listens, but the conversation ends without a clear next step. Jade is told she can come back if things get worse. She leaves unsure whether what she is experiencing is serious enough to ask for help again.

Trust is damaged

Later, the school contacts Jade’s parents.

Jade had not understood that this would happen or what parts of their conversation might be shared. At home, her parents are upset that she spoke to someone at school before talking to them.

For Jade, the conversation she hoped might make things easier now feels like it has created another problem. She becomes much more careful about what she says at school and stops talking about what is happening at home.

No one checks back in with her to explain what happened or ask whether she still wants support.

Her difficulties become more visible

Over the following weeks, Jade becomes increasingly tired and withdrawn. She starts arriving late, misses parts of the school day and falls behind with homework.

Her friendships begin to change too. Other students make comments about how quiet she has become and how she looks. At first Jade brushes them off, but the comments become more direct, and she starts avoiding certain corridors and spending more time alone.

Teachers begin noticing unfinished work and missed deadlines. Jade is reminded about her GCSEs and told that she needs to get back on track.

Because she is still achieving reasonably well, much of the focus remains on her work rather than on why so much has changed.

Support is offered too late

Jade becomes increasingly overwhelmed. At home she spends more time alone in her room and begins self-harming, hiding it from her family and from school.

Eventually, her year lead becomes concerned again and offers Jade school counselling. By now, Jade doesn’t want to go. She worries that other students will notice that anything she says might reach her parents, and that opening up will make things worse again.

When adults ask how she is, Jade says she is fine.

Jade’s difficulty is not that support is unavailable at school, but that accessing it depends on knowing where to go, feeling able to ask and trusting what will happen next. For young people whose distress is less visible, unclear routes into support, limited follow-up and uncertainty around confidentiality can make help feel difficult or risky to access — meaning problems can worsen even when support technically exists.

What we found

Children can receive varying levels and quality of mental health support in different schools. Evidence suggests that outcomes are shaped not only by individual interventions, but also by the wider school environment, relationships and culture in which support is delivered. 

We brought together evidence from a literature review, practitioner interviews and lived-experience engagement to understand what makes in-school mental health support work — and who is most affected when it doesn’t.

Literature review

  • Whole-school approaches are consistently associated with stronger outcomes than standalone interventions.
  • Trusted relationships are a key protective factor for children and young people.
  • Senior leadership commitment is critical to successfully implementing.
  • Staff wellbeing and pupil wellbeing are closely linked.
  • Mental health interventions are most effective when embedded within wider school culture and values.

Practitioner interviews

  • Trusted relationships were consistently described as central to successful support.
  • Whole-school approaches were viewed as more effective and sustainable than standalone interventions.
  • Strong leadership commitment influenced whether mental health became part of everyday school life.
  • MHST impact varied depending on school engagement and integration.
  • Whole-school cultures were viewed as more sustainable than isolated one-to-one interventions.

Lived experience interviews

  • Young people valued feeling safe, listened to and understood.
  • Positive experiences were often linked to supportive relationships with school staff.
  • Support was more helpful when it felt part of everyday school life rather than something accessed only in crisis.
  • Belonging and connection are important aspects of wellbeing.
  • Young people felt consistency and trust were often more important than the type of support provided.

“For some young people, walking up to a teacher and saying ‘I’m struggling’ can feel impossible. If school support is just a form tutor or a poster on the wall, it doesn’t feel like support. Young people need to know there is something helpful that they can trust.”

Groups Most Likely to be Affected

In-school support gaps don’t affect every pupil equally — some groups face a much higher risk of disengaging from school when support falls short.

Where is need greatest?

Why it matters

When in-school mental health support is ineffective, fewer needs are identified and supported early — pushing more children and young people towards specialist and crisis services later on. They may also lose trust in mental health support in future.

Greater demand for specialist mental health services

When in school mental health support is ineffective, fewer needs are identified and supported early leading to more escalations to clinical and crisis support.

Mental health admissions of children & young people to acute hospital wards rose 65% between 2012 and 2022 (24,198 to 39,925 admissions). A CAMHS inpatient admission costs around £61,000, compared with roughly £229 for six school-based counselling or CBT sessions.

Increased absence, exclusion and educational disengagement

Schools that are less able to provide the relationships and sense of belonging pupils need become less able to protect against absence and exclusion

1.34 million pupils (18.1%) were persistently absent in 2024/25, and persistent school absence could contribute to almost 180,000 pupils becoming unemployed or economically inactive — an estimated lifetime cost of £14 billion.

More children requiring support from multiple systems

Difficulties that could have been addressed within school instead escalate into wider system problems, drawing in additional services.

Severe emotional problems at age 16 were associated with around 29% higher GP costs in adulthood, with increased use persisting up to age 50.

Why is the system failing?

Building a better system

School is the de facto starting point for many complex mental health journeys. Getting this right requires a whole-school response that engages staff, children and young people, and parents together.

To support this shift, we have identified the following performance drivers that should guide how services operate:

What a better journey could look like

Improving the identification of unmet mental health needs, removing barriers to accessing support and strengthening coordination between schools, parents and mental health services will ensure more children & young people receive timely, appropriate and effective help.