Children Stuck Between Thresholds and Gatekeepers

Children and young people with emerging or complex mental health needs often fall between tiers of provision — too complex for universal services, but not meeting the threshold for specialist care. This can mean long waits for services that ultimately won’t meet their needs, inconsistent support, and escalating needs with no clear accountability for preventing deterioration. Awareness of local alternatives is often limited, and there’s little formal oversight of how well community and early-support services are working.

Our aim is to strengthen outcomes-focused navigation for children and young people, and system learning for single points of access, so that support is timely, effective, findable and properly funded.

The problem

35% of children and young people with active referrals to mental health services were still waiting for treatment at the end of March 2025. More than 60,000 had been waiting over two years.

Source: Children’s Commissioner (2026), Children’s and Young People’s Mental Health Services: 2024–25

The experience today

The case study below illustrates how the experience of being stuck between thresholds and gatekeepers can play out in practice. While fictional, the journey was co-designed with the Fixing Futures Young People’s Panel and draws on themes from our wider engagement with young people, families and practitioners, alongside the evidence.

Meet Jayden

Jayden is 10 and lives in Middlesbrough with his mum and younger sister. He is bright, funny and loves drawing football shirts and memorising train routes.

At home, life is often busy and stretched. His mum works shifts while caring for both children, and worries about money – they currently live in temporary housing, meaning there is not much room when something else starts to go wrong.

Things feel overwhelmeing

At first, Jayden starts complaining of stomach aches before school. He asks his mum if he can stay home and becomes upset on Sunday evenings.

At school, noisy classrooms and busy corridors feel overwhelming. He sometimes leaves lessons, gets tearful or shuts down when adults ask him what is wrong.

His mum knows something has changed, but Jayden cannot really explain it. School sees his attendance slipping and worries about his behaviour. His GP thinks anxiety may be part of it. Someone raises the possibility of autism or ADHD.

Jayden is seen by different people, who each notice something slightly different. His mum finds herself telling the same story again and again, without feeling much closer to knowing what will actually help him.

CAMHS does not accept his referral

As Jayden starts missing more school, a referral is made to CAMHS. His mum is relieved that someone might finally be able to help.

However, the referral is not accepted. Instead, the family is advised to try support through school, parenting support and a neurodevelopmental assessment.

School gives Jayden a calm-space card and arranges occasional check-ins, but he is still struggling to get through the day. The Mental Health Support Team feels that what is happening is becoming too complex for the support it can offer. A voluntary service is suggested, but it does not feel right for Jayden.

His mum goes back to the GP. The GP says another referral can be made if Jayden gets worse. School asks whether social care can help with some of the pressures at home. Social care directs the family back towards education and mental health support.

Meanwhile, Jayden is still getting up each morning frightened of school.

Jayden gets worse while waiting

Weeks turn into months. Some mornings Jayden cannot get dressed without becoming distressed. He begins missing whole weeks of school and spends more and more time in his room. His mum gets calls about his attendance while also trying to persuade him through the school gates.

When things become particularly difficult, she sometimes feels she has nowhere left to take him except A&E. On one visit, Jayden is assessed and goes home again with advice to follow up with the services already involved.

A few weeks later, things deteriorate further. Jayden tells his mum he does not want to be alive. They return to hospital and another urgent referral is made.

Even then, ongoing support does not appear straight away. There may be another assessment, another referral or another discharge home before somebody is able to offer sustained help. Each time, Jayden and his mum are asked what has happened, what has been tried and who else is involved.

A & E becomes the only option

For Jayden’s mum, A&E becomes both somewhere to turn when she has run out of options and somewhere they go when Jayden becomes too unwell to manage safely at home. For emergency staff, it means repeatedly trying to help a child whose difficulties have been building for months.

By the time Jayden begins receiving more consistent support, school has largely fallen away, his world has become much smaller, and his mum no longer expects that asking for help will necessarily lead to it.

Jayden’s difficulty is not that nobody notices he is struggling. It is that he needs more support than early services can provide, while still not meeting the threshold for specialist care. Without someone responsible for helping him find the right support, Jayden and his mum are passed between services while his difficulties worsen — until crisis becomes one of the only ways left to get help.

What We Found

We brought together evidence from a literature review, practitioner interviews and lived-experience engagement to understand why children fall between thresholds — and who is most affected.

Literature review

  • Children with moderate complexity needs often fall between universal, community and specialist support.
  • Community and voluntary sector provision is often fragmented, hard to navigate, or poorly integrated into referral pathways.
  • Children frequently deteriorate while professionals determine the most appropriate service response, and crisis services increasingly become the endpoint when earlier support hasn’t been successfully connected.

Practitioner interviews

  • Children are referred between services without a clear route to appropriate support, and repeated referrals often lead nowhere.
  • There’s no clear ownership of children whose needs don’t meet criteria for specialist intervention.
  • Children can be left without appropriate support while waiting for assessments, decisions or service availability.

Lived experience interviews

  • Trusted relationships and consistent explanations often matter as much as access to a specific type of service.
  • Families want support that feels personalised, flexible and focused on daily life — not just symptoms, diagnoses or risk.
  • Families are often left to navigate complex systems themselves, with limited guidance about what support is available or what to do next.

“The long wait for support made everything worse. I had no idea of when help would come, and in that gap things deteriorated to the point where I was in crisis. When you’re left waiting, no one is actually helping you get better – it’s like nothing is happening until you’re in full crisis, and then the response is all about safety, not treatment.”

Groups Most Likely to be Affected

Some groups of children are especially likely to fall into the gap between ‘too complex for universal support’ and ‘not meeting the threshold for specialist care.’

Where is the need greatest?

Why it matters

When children aren’t connected to appropriate support, needs often escalate over time. This shifts risk onto schools, families and communities, increases demand across multiple services, and drives poorer long-term outcomes at a higher cost to the public sector.

Escalation to crisis care

Children receive support later and at a higher level of need, increasing demand for emergency, acute and specialist services.

Mental health admissions of children and young people to acute hospital wards rose 65% between 2012 and 2022 (24,198 to 39,925 admissions). A CAMHS inpatient admission costs around £61,000, compared with roughly £229 for six school-based counselling or CBT sessions.

Risk is held by schools, families and VCSEs

Schools, families and community organisations become the default holders of risk, despite often lacking the capacity, expertise or resource to provide sustained support.

65% of school leaders reported that their school was fully or partially subsidising healthcare provision that should have been provided by health services.

More systems become involved

As needs escalate, children and families end up accessing multiple services at once, increasing complexity, coordination demands and cost.

78% of young people admitted to adolescent psychiatric inpatient units had already accessed A&E or a paediatric ward in the previous six months.

Why is the system failing?

Building a better system

We want to see better ownerships of children and young people’s support journeys through complex system where no child find themselves lost between waiting lists or without clear options to access support that works for them.

To support this shift, we have identified the following performance drivers that should guide how services operate: 

What a better journey could look like

Providing timely, needs-led support regardless of service thresholds, with clear pathways and active navigation between services, will prevent young people from falling through gaps, reduce delays and ensure they receive the right help before their needs escalate.

What a better journey could look like