Children and young people who are excluded from school or removed from the school roll can lose consistent access to trusted adults, support systems and oversight. Where exclusion is driven by school-level decisions, mental health needs may be a contributing factor but aren’t always properly identified or addressed. Children who have been excluded face an increased risk of unmet mental health needs, disengagement from services and poorer long-term outcomes.
Our aim is to apply outcomes-focused performance management to mental health support within exclusion pathways.
In England, 9,906 pupils were permanently excluded from school in 2024/25, alongside 913,000 recorded suspensions. Research suggests that school exclusion is associated with poorer long-term outcomes, including increased risks of unemployment, involvement in the criminal justice system and mental health difficulties.
Sources:
Department for Education (2026), Suspensions and permanent exclusions in England, 2024/25;
UCL (2024), Being excluded or truant from school leads to mental health problems – and vice versa
The case study below illustrates how children missing education can play out in practice. While fictional, the journey was co-designed with the Fixing Futures Young People’s Panel and draws on themes from our wider engagement with young people, families and practitioners, alongside the evidence.
Noah is 15 and a lives with his parents and younger brother. He is bright and enjoys practical subjects, particularly lessons involving making, building or solving problems. However, when he becomes overwhelmed, he may leave class, argue with staff or refuse instructions.
Adults tend to notice what Noah has done before asking what might have made the situation feel unmanageable for him.

Noah begins receiving detentions and being removed from lessons. After several incidents, he is suspended for short periods and placed on a behaviour report when he returns.
Different teachers respond differently. Some give him space to calm down; others expect him to comply immediately. Noah starts going into school expecting to get into trouble and feels that staff have already decided what kind of student he is.
His parents receive frequent calls asking them to collect him or discuss another incident. At home, Noah becomes quieter, sleeps badly and starts saying that he hates school.
The suspensions become more frequent. Meetings with school increasingly focus on whether mainstream education can continue to work for Noah.
His parents are exhausted. They are repeatedly leaving work to collect him, attending meetings and trying to persuade him to return after each suspension. They agree that a smaller or more specialist setting might suit him better, but there is no obvious place ready for him to move to.
Eventually, Noah leaves the school, with Alternative Provision or another placement expected to follow.
No placement is immediately available. Noah’s family receives calls from different professionals and repeatedly explains his behaviour, attendance and needs, but they are not given a clear timetable, interim education plan or named person responsible for his journey. At first, Noah is relieved not to be going back. Then the weeks begin to stretch.
As the weeks pass, communication becomes less consistent. Noah begins sleeping through the day, loses contact with friends and becomes increasingly anxious about returning to education. His parents try to maintain a routine while working, managing his distress and chasing services for updates.
What was intended to be a short transition becomes a prolonged break from education. Noah now needs support not only with the difficulties that led him to leave school, but also with rebuilding his routine, catching up with learning and managing anxiety about entering another setting.
Noah’s behaviour is what brings him to the attention of the system, but the needs underneath it can be lost as the focus shifts towards sanctions, suspensions and where he should be educated next. When a child leaves mainstream school without their mental health and wellbeing support moving with them, a change of placement can become a loss of trusted adults, routine and oversight — making it harder, rather than easier, for them to re-engage.
We brought together evidence from a literature review, practitioner interviews and lived-experience engagement to understand what happens when children lose consistent access to school — and who is most affected


“Everything was completely disrupted… I wasn’t allowed to go into school… my relationship with friends was completely ruined.”
Some groups of children and young people are especially likely to end up missing from mainstream education and can become harder to support once they are.
Long periods of absence can increase the risk of children & young people dropping out of education altogether and make it harder for them to return. Department of Education (DfE) guidance says that prolonged non-attendance, where no suitable alternative education is in place, can be a sign of neglect and in severe cases may amount to neglect.

When children fall out of education, their mental health needs can go unidentified and unsupported, increasing the risk of deteriorating wellbeing, disengagement and escalating demand on health, social care and other services.

Children become less visible to the universal services best placed to identify emerging needs — once out of school, they’re also less likely to attend health services or access informal support.
Referrals to children’s services fell by 10% when schools closed during the pandemic, compared with the previous three years — suggesting that at-risk children and young people remain invisible to social care when they are not in school.
Once mainstream education no longer provides a consistent protective environment, children are pushed towards costlier, more specialist forms of support.
A special needs placement costs a council roughly £6,000 per pupil per year in a mainstream school, compared with around £23,000 in a maintained special school and £40,000 in an independent or non-maintained special school. Pupils who end up in Alternative Provision (AP) are far more likely to be not in education, employment or training (NEET) — 14%, compared with 2% across the state sector as a whole.
Prolonged disconnection from education affects a young person’s successful transition into adulthood, shifting costs further down the line rather than resolving them.
The Institute for Public Policy Reseach (IPPR) estimated in 2017 the lifetime cost to the taxpayer of a single school exclusion at roughly £370,000, once alternative-setting education, lost future tax revenue, criminal justice contact, benefits payments and lifetime healthcare costs are all factored in.

Children and young people leaving the school roll need to be quickly supported to re-engage with meaningful activity that provides structure, purpose and connection.
To support this shift, we have identified the following performance drivers that should guide how services operate:
Services should identify and provide targeted support to children and young people at greater risk of missing education, using joined-up data from education, health and social care to prioritise cases and reduce vulnerability to abuse, exploitation and other safeguarding risks.

Earlier identification of children & young people at risk of missing education, combined with coordinated support and better managed transitions out of school, will reduce safeguarding risks, prevent prolonged disengagement from education and improve mental health outcomes.